Here's How The ClosetMaid System Stacks Up To Its Competitors

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Once you've noticed the biggest signs it's time to reorganize your closet, you might worry that your closet space just isn't built for keeping all your clothes. A closet with a solitary shelf is no good for organization; luckily, it's easy to revamp your closet with a modular storage system. By buying individual shelves, drawers, and clothing racks, you can upgrade your closet to exactly suit your needs. Or you can get a pre-planned kit to make the process even smoother. There are many closet system models on the market, but one of the biggest brands you'll see on your search is ClosetMaid. A great value for the price, ClosetMaid is a straightforward fix for most storage issues. But ClosetMaid isn't the only system out there —- brands like Elfa and Rubbermaid are also viable options.

ClosetMaid, Elfa, and Rubbermaid storage systems work pretty much the same, but there are a few key differences. Elfa is a very costly modular system, while the other two are more affordable. Although ClosetMaid and Rubbermaid systems may seem interchangeable, disparities in strength and customizability set each of these products apart.

The Container Store's Elfa storage system is beloved by interior decorators for its versatility and durability, but its quality comes at a high price point. However, Elfa is much more expensive than most other storage systems. For example, a premade Elfa kit for a six-foot-long closet costs over $700 (the premiere Elfa Decor+ version is even more at $1,800). For a fraction of that amount, you could get a similar closet kit from ClosetMaid that runs for about $150 on Amazon. Both Elfa and ClosetMaid storage systems are very durable, but Elfa components tend to last longer.

One major pro of Elfa systems is that they are easier to install. They are also a better option for renters since they require you to drill fewer holes into the wall. While the ClosetMaid system isn't necessarily difficult to put up, the process is more tedious, and it will take more effort to take down if you ever want to rearrange things. The good news is that if you install everything correctly and obey the weight limits, you won't have to worry about ClosetMaid components buckling. Similarly, Elfa components stay sturdy no matter how many times you move them around. Overall, these two systems perform well, but ClosetMaid is better for people on a budget. If you're still conflicted, check out our final verdict on whether the Elfa system is worth it.

Another huge player in the modular storage solutions world is Rubbermaid. The Rubbermaid system is very similar to the ClosetMaid option in price, style, and durability. You can grab a starter Rubbermaid system for $135 on Amazon, making it a few bucks cheaper than a comparable product from ClosetMaid. However, Rubbermaid components tend to not be as sturdy as other brands, though they are still plenty durable and can even be swapped out for ClosetMaid components if you prefer how they are made. Both storage systems have a simple design with white or plain metal wire shelves and hanging rods, so using them together can be a good way to organize your closet space as a renter.

Compared to ClosetMaid, Rubbermaid is much more customizable, thanks to how many extra accessories are available to incorporate into your storage system. ClosetMaid offers a few different drawers and organizers, but Rubbermaid has options like plastic shelves for the pantry or a tool rack for the garage. These two systems are pretty equal when it comes to quality, so the right choice for you will depend on your priorities. If you want to be able to move things around and install new components often, Rubbermaid might be best. But for those who prefer a straightforward system that will last years, ClosetMaid is a great choice.