Costco's Most Popular Ice Makers (And Which Brand Has The Best Reviews)

If you've ever been to a restaurant with "good ice," you know just how enjoyable those cold, crunchy nuggets are. Not only do they perfectly cool your beverage, but they are also delightful to munch on (shh, don't tell your dentist). If having the perfect ice in your home is something you'd be willing to shell out your money on, Costco has your back on these luxury kitchen appliances. Their immense inventory features several ice makers, each with its own pros and cons, giving you some homework to do before committing to a particular machine.

Among some of the most popular ice makers at Costco are the Frigidaire Gallery Nugget Ice Maker and the GE Profile Nugget Ice Maker. Each has hundreds of reviews, with many customers commenting on how much they love having their favorite ice on demand. The ice makers also have garnered their own TikTok fan videos from creators raving about their features. For example, @CostcoHotFinds showcased the former ice maker, which they proudly displayed on their kitchen counter. Another Costco TikTok account, @CostcoGuide, shared their finding of the GE model ice maker, including how excited they were to find one for under $300.

If the idea of a personalized ice maker is truly tempting you, the pros and cons of each appliance can provide some much-needed clarity before you commit. First and foremost is determining whether or not the price is worth it. The Frigidaire Gallery appliance is available on Costco's website for $199.99, while the GE Profile model is significantly more expensive (anywhere from $270 to $579, based on information from the corresponding TikTok video). Another aspect to consider is how to clean your ice machine and maintain it.

Both machines have comments on TikTok criticizing their maintenance and cleaning. One user noted the sheer noise of the machine, as well as the work associated with keeping the Frigidaire model clean. Meanwhile, an individual who purchased the GE model claims that the maintenance is a lot of work, despite the fact that she readily admits how much she loves it. 

65% of GE buyers offer a 5-star review on the product. They mention everything from how quickly it works to the benefit of it coming with filters to keep the ice fresh. On the other hand, a large percentage of buyers do criticize the machine, with 12% of buyers believing it to be deserving of the lowest rating available. The Frigidaire model has a 55% full-approval rating from its customers who enjoy its high production capacity, but 10% left 1-star reviews, most of which comment on how noisy the machine is. If you're on the fence about a pricey model, consider the cheaper Frigidaire Bullet Ice Maker, available from Costco for $79.99, with a 65% 5-star rating.