7 Times Fans Were Left Unimpressed By HGTV Stars' Homes

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

These polarizing renovations are proof that HGTV stars are just like us! Everyone makes questionable design choices now and then, including your favorite HGTV personalities. While we are obsessed with watching them complete home makeovers on each of their respective programs, it's even more fascinating to witness how they choose to design their own homes. Although some HGTV stars have decorated their homes in a predictable aesthetic, others have made more unexpected design choices.

Thanks to home tours available on YouTube, fans have been able to weigh in on the interiors of many HGTV favorites. While there are always positive comments in support of their creative choices, other viewers have pointed out some major issues in their homes. Although everyone has a different opinion on what looks luxurious, we've highlighted the interior details that multiple fans have panned. Take note of these divisive choices so that you can avoid making the same mistakes in your own home.

Known for their wholesome "Home Town" renovations, Ben and Erin Napier always add a touch of character to their homes. When it came to their own project, many fans praised Ben and Erin for creating a rustic space that felt true to their signature style. However, there was one room that garnered some negative buzz on YouTube. Some fans weren't too keen on the quirky upper-floor upgrades – particularly the loud wallpaper in the bedroom. @nylanelson8660 writes, "I liked the house Until I saw All that Hideous Wallpaper on the walls upstairs." @inolagranville7832 adds, "Well, let's be honest mothers of course are going to love the house and it is a beautiful house some of the choices of the wallpaper I'm not impressed with[...]"

While wallpaper can be a great way to add visual interest to a space, it's important to choose the right pattern. If Erin and Ben's selection looks too busy for your taste, go with a more classic option like this floral wallpaper from Amazon. You could wallpaper only an accent wall as opposed to the entire room as a less overwhelming alternative. Even if you prefer a solid color wall, don't write off wallpaper altogether. In fact, wallpaper can be superior to paint if your room needs an affordable refresh.

Alison Victoria transformed an old factory into a luxurious space for living and working. However, fans were split in deciding whether the end result was classy or gaudy. @warrenhenning8064 comments on YouTube: "The marble in the kitchen is ghastly. The house alternates between being gaudy, boring and ugly. If she wasn't paying to have stupid fireplace mantels imported from France, she wouldn't have liquidity issues during the project and minor overages wouldn't be a problem." @Arunfiable comments with a similar sentiment, "It's tacky :(" Other users reply in agreement, including @UR_Right24, "I agree," and @laurend8335: "Agree. It looks like an office building with no windows and no yard converted into a home....which is exactly what it is."

There's a fine line between luxury and gaudiness. While Victoria didn't go overboard with opulent decor, it was primarily the finishes that bothered the public. Stone surfaces like marble can look classy in the right setting, but it's more cost-effective to use an alternative like quartz with faint, subtle marbling. The other primary issue with Victoria's home was the lack of relatability when it came to her blown-out budget. Most homeowners can't afford to go above and beyond their ceiling, which is why sometimes it's better to select affordable materials and surfaces with a similar style. For example, explore these flooring materials that aren't worth the price – and discover the best options to choose instead.

Chip and Joanna Gaines have had a fall from grace among some fans. While most everyone found their original "Fixer Upper" renovations charming and relatable, their current endeavors have turned off some former viewers. Rather than receiving negative feedback on the renovation itself, there was more criticism regarding their excessive lifestyle and wasteful design choices. Yahoo.com shares a quote from a viewer, "I don't like watching HGTV personalities renovating their own luxury 2nd or 3rd home. It looks like they're showing off." Realtor.com cites another fan comment regarding the duo's unnecessary waste: "That's sad about the glass. REPURPOSE maybe?"

In recent years, there has been a growing movement to salvage existing structural and decorative elements in older homes rather than tear them out. Although it used to be commonplace, and even praised, to flip a home in a contemporary style, the new name of the game is restore rather than renovate. This directly conflicts with Chip and Joanna's long history of transforming fixer-uppers. The ever-changing host of microtrends can also lead to renovations being unsustainable. To avoid falling into the trap of destroying your home's timeless features, try adding decor pieces that can be easily changed as your tastes change. Take a cue from these simple rental upgrades that won't permanently damage your home.