Home Depot Or Lowe's: Which Has Better Deals On Roof Shingles?

Replacing the shingles on your roof can easily become a complicated and costly task. Make It Right recommends choosing a shingle type that will boost your curb appeal. Roofing that contains unappealing black streaks or other defects can lower the cost of your home should you ever decide to sell it. In addition, it's also crucial to consider the weather climate in your area. Depending on your region, you'll need shingles that can hold up steadily against strong winds, snow, rain, and other tropical storms.

As per Consumer Reports, one of the most important factors to consider when purchasing your new roof is the warranty. Usually, most companies offer a lifetime warranty; however, this is usually only good for the life of the shingles — which is about 10 years. Once you've decided on the type of shingle you'll need, you then have to decide where you're going to purchase it. While you can buy roofing materials at many retailers, Lowe's and Home Depot each have a wide variety of options to choose from. Here are the best deals on roof shingles you can get at each store.

The best-selling roof shingle brand that Home Depot sells is made by GAF. Each pack costs a little less than $40 and covers just over 33 square feet. It's resistant to algae and available in many colors, including charcoal, barkwood, driftwood, and oyster gray. However, First American Roofing & Siding recommends choosing a simple color such as gray or black as they work for any home and never become outdated. There are a wide variety of warranties you can choose from as well including a standard limited lifetime warranty, 25-year StainGuard protection, and a limited transferable lifetime warranty with Smart Choice Protection, just to name a few.

This product has been reviewed over 6,000 times and has an overall rating of 4.9. In addition, it was recommended by 98% of the consumers who purchased it. One consumer stated that they conducted extensive research before deciding upon this brand and were pleased with the results. Another said they looked into several other brands before deciding that this product was the right one for them. They went on to add that they couldn't be happier with the end result.

In comparison, one of Lowe's most popular shingles brands is made by Owens Corning. It is slightly cheaper at just under $33. These come in a total of 14 colors including onyx black, brownwood, shasta white, and desert tan. Much like other brands, this product also includes resistance to algae. There are a few warranties you can choose from such as a 25-year limited option and a 60 mph wind-resistant warranty.

This design received a 4.8-star rating and was reviewed just over 2,200 times. It's widely recommended by many consumers including one who said they were surprised at how good the quality of these shingles are as well as how easy they were to install. Another buyer chimed in saying that these shingles looked beautiful on their red brick home. They went on to say that they recently experienced winds that exceeded 60 mph and they had no problem with them.

While Home Depot's shingles have more options in regards to the warranty, we have to say the better deal is at Lowe's. This retailer is a bit cheaper and has an extra color to choose from.